Learn how attorneys use challenges for cause and peremptory challenges during jury selection to ensure a fair trial in your New York personal injury case.

What Are Jury Challenges in New York?

After a pool of potential jurors is assembled for your personal injury or medical malpractice trial, attorneys for both sides have the opportunity to exclude certain individuals from serving on the jury. This process occurs during voir dire, the jury selection phase where attorneys question prospective jurors to identify any biases, conflicts of interest, or other factors that might affect their ability to be fair and impartial.

New York law provides two distinct methods for removing prospective jurors: challenges for cause and peremptory challenges. While both serve to shape the final jury, they operate under very different rules and serve different purposes. Understanding how these challenges work can help you appreciate how your attorney works to secure a fair jury for your case.

The jury that ultimately decides your case can significantly impact the outcome, making the strategic use of these challenges a critical component of trial preparation and advocacy.

Challenges for Cause: Removing Biased Jurors

A challenge for cause is a request to the judge to dismiss a prospective juror for a specific, legally recognized reason that would prevent that person from being fair and impartial. Unlike peremptory challenges, there is no limit to the number of for-cause challenges an attorney can make—as long as a valid legal basis exists.

Common grounds for challenges for cause in New York personal injury and medical malpractice cases include:

  • Bias or prejudice: The prospective juror has expressed a fixed opinion about the case, the parties, or the type of claim that suggests they cannot be impartial
  • Relationship to a party: The juror knows one of the parties, attorneys, or witnesses personally
  • Financial interest: The juror has a financial stake in the outcome of the case
  • Prior experience: The juror has been involved in a similar case or situation that has created a strong bias
  • Inability to follow the law: The juror states they cannot apply the law as instructed by the judge, such as refusing to award damages for pain and suffering or being unable to hold a doctor liable
  • Physical or mental incapacity: The juror cannot hear, see, understand, or otherwise participate effectively in the trial

To succeed with a challenge for cause, your attorney must demonstrate to the judge that a specific legal ground exists. The judge has discretion to grant or deny these challenges based on the prospective juror’s responses during questioning. If a juror admits they cannot be fair, or if their answers reveal clear bias, the judge will typically excuse them from service.

Peremptory Challenges: Strategic Jury Selection

A peremptory challenge allows an attorney to exclude a prospective juror without providing any reason or justification to the court. These challenges are limited in number and are considered a valuable strategic tool during jury selection. In New York civil cases, including personal injury and medical malpractice trials, each side is typically allowed six peremptory challenges in Supreme Court cases, though this number may vary depending on the court and type of case.

Attorneys use peremptory challenges based on their assessment of which jurors might be less favorable to their client’s case. This assessment may be based on body language, tone of responses, life experiences, profession, or other factors that suggest a juror might be sympathetic to the opposing side—even when no legally sufficient basis exists for a challenge for cause.

However, peremptory challenges are not unlimited in their application. Under the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Batson v. Kentucky and its progeny, attorneys cannot use peremptory challenges to exclude jurors based solely on race, ethnicity, gender, or other protected classifications. If one side believes the other is using peremptory challenges in a discriminatory manner, they can raise a Batson challenge, requiring the attorney to provide a race-neutral or gender-neutral explanation for the strike.

The strategic use of both challenges for cause and peremptory challenges requires skill and experience. Your attorney must balance the goal of removing potentially unfavorable jurors with the limited number of peremptory challenges available, all while working to seat a jury that will fairly evaluate the evidence and apply the law to your case.

Frequently asked questions

What happens if the judge denies my attorney's challenge for cause?

What happens if the judge denies my attorney’s challenge for cause?

Can I help my attorney decide which jurors to challenge?

Can I help my attorney decide which jurors to challenge?

Related

Injured in New York? Alan Ripka & Associates offers a free, confidential case review in English, Spanish, or Russian. Call 212-557-4777.

Attorney Advertising. This article is general information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different; prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. For advice about your situation, contact Alan Ripka & Associates, LLP at 212-557-4777 for a free consultation.

CategoryPersonal Injury
Write a comment:

*

Your email address will not be published.

logo-footer